ILI Benchmarking – Ensuring an Adequate Understanding of ILI Capability Under Real-World Operating Conditions

Abstract & paper, presented at the Pipeline Technology Conference (PTC) 2021
Modern inline inspection tools offer an unequalled method to rapidly inspect pipeline systems for a range of damage mechanisms and have undoubtably assisted reduction of incident rates within the pipeline industry. Cost of inline inspection can be high; in costs of preparation such as cleaning pig runs, increase of headcount on or in controlled installations, cost of reduced production in addition to the actual cost of the inspection by the ILI tool.
Inspection tool efficacy is therefore a key consideration, particularly in cases where secondary costs in addition to the actual ILI tool vendor cost are comparatively high. In these cases, the overall cost benefit analysis of ILI tool can give an increased incentive to contract the best technology and tool available. Commonly the data driving the cost benefit analysis is provided by the specific ILI tool vendor; so how can operators verify the claims of the ILI vendors and prove comparative ILI tool efficacy between vendors under real-world operating conditions?
Recent advances in computational capability of commonly available computer hardware has enabled increased capability in analysis conducted on large datasets. This includes the
capability to conduct statistical analysis of every feature detected by multiple inline inspections across many individual pipelines.
The authors combine techniques commonly used to predict corrosion growth rate such as statistical correlation of inline inspection results, with many inline inspection datasets and
advanced data science techniques. The various techniques utilised by the authors to analyse the claimed probability of detection and sizing tolerances of various ILI tools are broadly based on regression modelling with additional techniques where required for algorithm optimisation.
The authors will detail a typical anonymised output of statistical analysis of multiple ILI vendors and ILI tools and will explain the insights that this can provide, irrespective of ILI vendor claimed specifications. The authors will demonstrate that the methodology allows an unbiased analysis of ILI tool capability under real-world operating conditions, and how this can be used to better inform the cost benefit analysis process used when selecting a specific ILI vendor and ILI tool.
Get in Touch with Our Experts
Contact Us
"*" indicates required fields
Contact Us
"*" indicates required fields
To read the full paper presented at the Pipeline Technology Conference 2021, download a PDF copy below
Insights & News

Demystifying Hydrogen Fatigue Crack Growth
With the increasing momentum to adopt clean fuels coupled with the scrutinised investment horizons of maintaining ageing gas pipelines, there are well-established and mutually beneficial...

Energy – the final frontier?
The transition from a career developing structures for use in space to solving the challenges of implementing hydrogen infrastructure may not seem straightforward, but for Penspen’s Head of...

What Are the Key Integrity Considerations When Repurposing Pipelines for Hydrogen?
With the European Hydrogen Backbone targeting 52,000 km of hydrogen pipelines by 2040 - 60% of which will be repurposed from existing infrastructure - ensuring the integrity of these pipelines will...

Beyond Compliance: Optimisation Opportunities of the Gas Mega Rule – Pipeline Integrity Management with Digital Twins, Multiple Inspections, and Artificial Intelligence
In a new technical paper presented at the 2025 Pipeline Pigging and Integrity Management Conference, Penspen, Senslytics, and PipelineLogic explore how Penspen's THEIA platform and Causal AI...

Penspen Joins Hydrogen UK to Drive the Future of Clean Energy in the UK
International engineering consultancy reinforces commitment to sustainable energy by becoming an official member of the UK’s leading hydrogen trade association. Penspen, a leading international...

Penspen Reports $120 Million Worth of New Contract Awards Secured in Second Half of 2024
Company’s comprehensive engineering expertise helps improve energy access for communities worldwide Penspen today announces a positive finish to the fiscal year with $120 million awarded in new...

Penspen Shortlisted for 2025 Hydrogen UK Annual Awards
International engineering consultancy Penspen has been shortlisted as finalists at the 2025 Hydrogen UK Annual Awards. The Hydrogen UK Annual Conference and Awards is the premier event celebrating...